Reviewed
by: Howard
Carson, December 2004,
updated May 2005
Published
by: Symantec
Requires: Pentium
computer; Windows 98, Me, 2000, XP, Media Center Edition,
Tablet PC Edition; 264MB available hard disk space
and an additional 10% of your total hard disk space
for GoBack's history files; DirectX 8 or higher
MSRP: US$69.95
(Standard), US$99.95 (Premier)
You
may think that a quick browse through the Windows
'temp' folder, a few deletions and a perfunctory
sally through a few other obvious locations is enough
to keep the adware, spam, hijackers and worms at
bay. You'd be wrong. Windows XP is so unreservedly
complex that any seriously thorough clean out of
all the detritus, nonsense and idiocy collected deliberately
(and inadvertently too, for sure) while downloading,
surfing the 'Net and just sending and receiving e-mail,
requires a program created by a team of highly skilled
designers and programmers. Life in Windowsland is
most assuredly not simple. Thus, spake the computer
muses, you need something which digs deep, understands
the vagaries of Windows itself, recognizes the degree
to which hijackers, worms, viruses and tracking attacks
can pollute a typical PC, and yet presents you with
a user interface which does not require an engineering
degree to figure out. Say hello to Norton SystemWorks
2005.
Norton
SystemWorks 2005 is a comprehensive set of utilities
which reside within a single user interface—a
set of individual utility modules controlled through
a single master panel if you will. It's a common
design approach for this sort of powerful tool
set and we've seen almost identical approaches
in PentaSuite, SystemSuite and other top-drawer
utility software. SystemWorks 2005 is used to scan
your system for faults, useless files, dangerous
files, fragmented files, messed up Registry entries,
viruses, worms, trojans, hijackers and hardware
problems, getting rid of all the junk it finds,
optimizing your system as it goes and keeping track
of everything you install so that in the event
of a problem, you can roll back the state of your
computer to a point in time when it worked properly.
|
|
Several
elements of SystemWorks 2005 are available as standalone
programs from Symantec including Norton AntiVirus, Norton
Utilities and Norton GoBack. SystemWorks 2005 also incorporates
Smith Micro Software's CheckIt Diagnostics. The SystemWorks
2005 Premier version includes Symantec Recovery Disk and
Norton Ghost v9. Obviously, the feature and function set
in SystemWorks 2005 is enormous. What we wanted to find
out was whether or not all the superior benchmarks SystemWorks
2005 has set in controlled test situations would stand
up under rigorous real-world use on a couple of very busy
business computers. We also wanted to find out how easy
to use it would be for non-technical people.
Installation
of SystemWorks 2005 is a lengthy process—an hour
or more including all extras and a full system scan.
The software installs its detection and cleaning hooks
deep into Windows. We installed SystemWorks 2005 on two
computers: a) a Pentium 4/2.8GHz office productivity
system used for word processing, spreadsheets, e-mail,
and online research, and b) a Pentium 4/3.2GHz graphics
system used for desktop publishing, image/photo editing
and some video editing. Both systems see dozens, if not
hundreds of new files which arrive from sources all over
the place every day. Both systems also run MSN Messenger
6.x and Yahoo Instant Messenger. Both systems had been
running V-Com's SystemSuite 5 administered by an IT technician
on a weekly basis. The requirement for this review was
that the actual computer users would have to add computer
maintenance to their regular activities.
We
set up a schedule which required both computer users
to do maintenance on their machines three times per week,
taking no more than 30 minutes each time. We also made
sure that both users thoroughly read the SystemWorks
2005 manual and online help from beginning to end. As
a group, the three of us also reviewed SystemWorks 2005
after the second week of regular use. It was a useful
little meeting that revealed some surprising results.
First and foremost, it turns out we all agreed on which
components were the most frequently used (and by implication
also the most useful): System Optimizer - customizes
every major aspect of Windows, WinDoctor - complete analysis,
repair and clean up of the entire Registry, and WipeInfo
- secure erasure of data and all records of program,
file and Internet use.
Cons: Norton
SystemWorks 2005 includes a number of functions which
requires the installation of extra utilities, all of
which are supplied on the program CD. It's a mystery
why everything isn't installed in the first place considering
that since the main installation takes about an hour
anyway (including a full system scan), what real difference
would a few more minutes make in order to get everything
installed from the CD? Norton GoBack, CheckIt Diagnostics,
Norton CleanSweep, System Doctor and System Information
require separate installs. Installing new software which
uses poorly designed installation scripts can give you
a headache when the Norton antivirus component is running.
What happens is that Norton starts to check each and
every new file being installed which is fine and dandy
unless the new program's installer happens to use a poorly
designed script or otherwise writes files in a manner
which alerts Norton to potential problems. The result
is either a computer which slows to a crawl, or an aborted
installation of the new program. There's no way to know
for sure when problems like this are going to happen,
so we recommend disabling any antivirus program when
installing brand name software at least. The SystemWorks
2005 user interface does not provide enough up-front
plain language explanation to inexperienced users about
what's going on. That sometimes makes it difficult for
such users to commit themselves to deleting trash files,
tracking cookies and other much worse files when clean
up results appear and decisions have to be made about
what files to kill and what files to keep.
Pros: That
Symantec has figured out how to effectively design and
produce this sort of software after so many years of
pounding away at it is not surprising. There's lots of
competent competition too, but Symantec with its Symantec
Antivirus Resource Center (SARC) and a support web site
the size of a small county, has learned the hard way
that installing this kind of software on millions of
computers comes with certain responsibilities. The antivirus
component detected every single nasty virus, worm, trojan
and hijack thing which flowed into our inbox during three
weeks of continuous daily use—no misses, no problems.
Outbound e-mail is scanned and cleaned of viruses and
other stupidity just as thoroughly as inbound e-mail.
The file protection routines in SystemWorks 2005 work
like a charm and essentially prevent anything from modifying
the Registry and key system files unless the changes
are absolutely safe. Registry cleaning was flawless,
providing improvements in boot up and general operational
speeds. Straightforward wizards guide users through hard
disk and Internet browser cleanups. Lots of emergency
recovery tools including the ability to create startup
disks, CD images of key disk information, and full compatibility
with Windows NTFS partitions as well as FAT and FAT32
partitions. SystemWorks 2005 is the only product of its
type right now that features full compatibility with
XP (all versions), Windows Media Center Edition and Tablet
PC Edition. The version we tested and the Premier edition
are well worth the money. SystemWorks 2005 (in any version)
will protect your PC, stabilize your PC, clean up your
PC, restore your PC, recover lost files on your PC and
general help to prevent you from making a fool of yourself.
We never expected our review guinea pigs to memorize
the product documentation we forced them to read thoroughly
before installing SystemWorks 2005. What the reading
process did however was prepare both people for a number
of situations in which they found problems during systems
maintenance and scans. Because both people had read the
product documentation from beginning to end, they quickly
turned back to the documentation to help them decide
what to do to solve the problems discovered by the software
rather than sitting back and dithering about the problems.
The expression RTFM applies nowhere more appropriately
than it does with Norton SystemWorks 2005. RTFM and you
will be happy, your computer will be happy, and you'll
enjoy a lot of trouble-free time with your PC. Highly
recommended.